Ask a Question Answer a question Read/Write Articles Rate Members Watch Videos
Read Articles
Sign Up










tough-situation

Can I win her back?

Average Rating: Not yet rated!
Your Rating: 
MiserableBoringEnjoyableInterestingFascinating
 
tough-situation (Age:30 to 35)     When: 3 months ago
Views: 186     Category: Break-Up
I had asked a question which I will post below. The responses are good but I am meeting with my ex on Tuesday. She is open to meeting up and has kept contact but has been a bit weird. I can't read if she really wants to be broken up and just stay friends or if she wants me to fight for her. How can I figure out when I meet her whether she wants me to fight for her (even though she'll probably say let's just be friends)?

I met a girl and we dated for one month before she told me that she didn't love me. Here's the back story. We met online, had a first date and ended up spending practically the whole day together. Then spent the next two days seeing each other and basically fell into a relationship. A week later, as I was going on a vacation trip to NY to visit family, I asked her to come along as I couldn't stand the idea of not seeing her for a week. We had fun in NY and then came back and kept going out and hanging out together. Over these 4 weeks, I learned a lot about her. She was the first to ask to be exclusive a week into the relationship and I really dug her.similar hobbies, she did lots of things I like, we basically were fine. I unfortunately found out her last three b/f's cheated on her and in the last relationship, while she was 8 weeks pregnant. Further, she has dizzy spells which I think are psychosomatic and related to her troubled relationships although she says it's because of her work. Finally, I find out she was sexually molested as a child. Long story short, the relationship was going fine. These things didn't bother me. Yet, last Sunday, she says out of the blue we have to talk and says she doesn't love me and can't be with someone whom she doesn't love. I was shocked by this and definitely didn't feel her actions signaled this. Further, I was shocked to hear her tell me how great I am, how much of a gentleman I was but she simply didn't click. The first 4 weeks it seemed fine. She never said slow down or anything like that.I would have had she shown some concern. Anyway, I fell for her hard. Is it worth fighting for her and how? Or basically, should I forget about her and move on?

3000 characters left  Anonymous Spell Check Spell Check
 Report Question  Email Friend Widgets Note This
Answers
  Hide Comments From Guys  
2
From Girls  
3
 

What Girls Said

Selected as Best Answer
lost-angel
2093  
lost-angel (Age:25 to 29)      When: 2 months ago
If she wanted you to fight for her. She wouldn't say she is NOT in love with you. Because just like "i love you", "I am not in love you" is also pretty strong. And it is something very difficult to say to someone you love. She might've said something like, "I need space", or "I'm not sure I can be in a relationship, right now. " stuff like that. She would say something that would keep the "situation" open.
In this situation however, she straight up said she doesn't love you. And she means it. The reason why she still wants you around is because you and her get along, as FRIENDS.
There are a lot of guys we meet, who we think are perfect. Gentleman, funny, smart, successful. etc. But there is a certain character in each man that triggers our attraction, and makes us see them as more than a friend. In your case, you are one of those perfect guys, but not the type she is attracted to. She wasn't trying to hint when she explained that to you. She was being honest, because you are good guy, and she doesn't want to lead you on to something that's not going to happen.
If you really care about this girl, and it won't hurt you to be her FRIEND, then move on as a friend. Because you never know, maybe someday she will realize she wants more from you.
(don't hope for it though)
But if you know you will keep falling for her, and it will hurt you to see her with another guy. Then quit seeing/contacting her, until you are totally over her.
Im sorry for what happened. But you can't force her to love you. And trust me, I would know if a girl wanted the guy to "fight" for her.

Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker Thanks, that's pretty sound advice. At this point, I've moved on. She actually ended up getting accepted to a university way too far to realistically manage a relationship. I've decided to move on she it felt like beating a dead horse. Once I got over the "shock" of the break-up I actually analyzed all the baggage she had and concluded that it would probably have been very difficult to have a healthy relationship with her anyway. Simply too many problems she has to deal with first on her end! - 2 months ago

brokenhearted4
5  
brokenhearted4 (Age:25 to 29)      When: 3 months ago
I don't think you should pursue this anymore. I am reading a book and it talks about relationships and how they shouldn't be that hard. If you are meant to be together you will end up together. I think she needs some major counseling. If she says she doesn't love you why would you want to be with her. I think there is someone waiting for you and her problems won't get in the way.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

NatalieChristine112
1335  
NatalieChristine112 (Age:Under 18)      When: 3 months ago
Sounds similar to my story, except for the fact that I’m much younger and there were no ex girlfriends that my ex had. Since she was hurt so many times, she may have a tendency to fall away from guys, and in her mind telling herself that she’s not meant for you-she may not be. But you need to love on her with the boundaries that she has given you. Since you’re not dating, don’t try to grab her hand, or try to kiss or hug her. You need to love on her and let her know that you’re here for her. She’ll fall into your arms in time. Be an amazing friend to her, let her know that you two can talk about anything, if she needs to talk about getting molested let her, if she cries with you hold her. Like I said- Love on her with the boundaries that she has given you.
If it’s meant to be, it’s meant to be. If you would move on then that would mean that you would’ve given up on her… if you were crazy about her before why not be crazy about her now even though she doesn’t want an intimate relationship with you. She will value the strength of the love and care that you have for her if you don’t give up. Don’t be stalkerish, be a great friend and be a help toward her life.

Good luck<3
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   1
Report
 

What Guys Said

Rafael151
1944  
Rafael151 (Age:Over 45)      When: 3 months ago
The thing I've learned about girls who want you to fight for them is that a few (not all) need it not just once, but always. If she falls in that group, and a suitable confrontation doesn't come up again on it's own, she will seize upon or create scenarios that cause you to always need to fight to keep her. Or she will at least test you.creating smaller situations so she at least knows if you are ready and willing.
Your girlfriend or wife is occasionally going to be the object of some guys advances.often shrugged off and you won't hear about it. The girl I'm talking about needs to know that you won't ever let something like that go unanswered. So you will hear about every occurrence. When I hear the words "fight for her" that's what comes to mind. I shouldn't let it, because as I said, it's just some who need that. I think it's an insecurity thing. But just food for thought, in case that sounds familiar.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

SexGod1
2994  
SexGod1 (Age:30 to 35)      When: 3 months ago
I have gone through this situation with a girl in the past. It can be very complicated, so I will try to be as thorough with my advice as possible. Personally, I agree with you that she totally gave you mixed signals, and I totally understand where you're coming from when it comes to being confused as to what you should do - fight for her or not. Since you know a bit of her history, you can understand that there is a possibility that she may just be scared of having a committed relationship with someone due to the sexual abuse in her past. However, women who are sexually abused sometimes find themselves unable to say no to guys. They can have a tendency to just go along with whatever the guy wants because they are afraid to say no. So, having said that, the only way to know whether she really likes you and is into you without pushing her is to allow her to have her space. Also, from a normal standpoint, when a girl tells you that she doesn't really love you, she normally means what she says. This can be the most hurtful thing for a guy to hear from someone that you really like/love, but if she says it, 9 times out of 10, you can believe that it's true. In a normal situation, if this occurs, you should drop the girl immediately and move on because she truly means what she says and she doesn't want a relationship where she is not in love with the person. There is the other 10% of women, however, who say something like this for a number of reasons: they are fearful of commitment, they don't really know how they feel, they want to hurt you, they are testing you, etc.But, like I said, for the most part, you can believe a girl when she says this because most women are looking for someone they feel totally in love with. In any case, whatever the situation, it would probably be in your best interest to respect her wishes of not being with her in that way at this time. Also, if you give her time and space, she will have time to find out what she really wants. If you are what she really wants, she will have time to figure that out. However, I would be careful to not get your hopes up. Sorry - this is probably not what you want to hear! However, I hope that you will have the strength to get through this because I know that it's probably really hard for you right now!
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker You are most likely right and as you said, the chance of 10% doesn't give me much hope that she does love me and simply isn't ready to show it. I think I'll simply stay friends with her and make sure to not let it eat me up. Fortunately, it was a 4 week relationship and as quickly as it started, it will probably go away (the hurt of it not working out). I think the most important thing for me is to move on with my life and start dating other girls. Who knows, maybe then she'll see "clearer". - 3 months ago
Answerer Yeah, well, I guess ya never know what's going to happen! - 3 months ago
 
Related Questions
Search
A Guy Asked How to win her back?
Well, my situation is that there is a girl who has liked me for a long time, but I waited too long to let her know that I like her in return, and now...   View Answers
A Guy Asked How can I win her back ?
we have been together for two years in new zealand. she was studying medicine and I was doing my master in IT, I was telling her that we have to move...   View Answers
Find more questions on
win her back
Home > Break-Up Questions > Can I win her back?
 
   Not a member yet? Sign Up for FREE in 1 easy step!
  
My Icon
0
Questions View
Answers View
Stories/Articles View
Messages View
Shout Outs View
Reality Check Create
Notebook View
Advice on Video
Break-Up Videos
Click on video to play

Advice: How To Deal With A Broken Heart
How much would you spend on him/her
rox-xox asked 3 days ago

$10-$30

$30-$50

$50-$100

$100 +

None. I would make something

Invite a Friend
Invite Friend
Break-Up Articles
 
●  My Story~ My Romeo is Dead
by  gingerXsnap
Well, most of you know me, as either gingerXsnap or as my name is real life, Ruby. Well, I am a 16 year old girl in high school, I love music, I love art, I am involved in almost every academic or...
●  Breaking up is hard to do- Making up is harder
by  teesand
There is an old song called "Breaking up is hard to do". Later on in the song the lyrics say "I wish that we were making up again". This song summarizes some relationships perfectly. Without a...
Browse Categories: Flirting  |   Dating  |   Relationships  |   Sexuality  |   Break-Up  |   Behavior  |   Style  |   Other                                         Home Top
  Site Links     About GirlsAskGuys     GirlsAskGuys Widgets     Help Us Improve!   RSS Feeds
Home
Videos
Partners
Search Questions
Terms of Use, Privacy
Help
About Us
Contact Us, Send Feedback
Sitemap
Advertise With Us
Links
Post your questions on your blog, website, or any social networking page. You can embed into MySpace, Facebook and more. Click here for more info.
Have a suggestion? See a problem on the site? Click here to give feedback and suggestions on the new GirlsAskGuys, and help us give you a better experience. Visit our blog here
 Subscribe
Add to My AOL
Add to Google Reader or Homepage
©2008 girlsaskguys.com™. All Rights Reserved.