Am I wierd for not finding guys that look like Abercrombie models attractive?

Honestly, guys that look/act like that are usually gay - so I'm not surprised that your feminine intuition is picking up one that .

The body language in the shots for their ads is a dead give-away

That's understandable as I would not want a girl who muscles are bigger than mine or a girl who weighs more then me.

I don't find them attractive... well I mean I do, but I don't go gaga over them like most girls do. I would never date a guy like that for the exact same reasons you said -- there's no way I would date a guy who took longer to get ready then me! Plus I kind of associate Abercrombie models with snobs anyway :P

Never really liked pretty boys until recently and gave me off a vibe that he's gay - so yea not really into them and they are just too feminine I mean if he gives me an advice on how to do my nails you know there's something wrong there ! Lol

I'm like that too. I don't go for pretty boys because they're cute, but just don't do it for me and are not my type. I like rough around the edges guys. Everyone has their own preferences, just because they like AF models doesn't mean you have to.

I use that same reasoning "too pretty". I feel like they are trying more than me, I also find them to be more feminine in that respect. I also have a bit off a stereotype for guys like that : snobs, I can't help it, they all (that I have met) seem that way.