Home | New Members | Expert Answers | How To Videos | Our Blog | Sign Up | Sign In
Invite Friends
 
GirlsAskGuys.com GirlsAskGuys.com
  Chat Flirting Dating Relationships Sexuality Break-Up Behavior Style Other
Anonymous User

What would she have to do for you to take her back?

Average Rating:
Your Rating: 
MiserableBoringEnjoyableInterestingFascinating
 
Anonymous User (Age:25 to 29)     When: A month ago
Views: 307     Category: Relationships

Short story: I've been in a long distance relationship with my boyfriend for 2 1/2 years. (We were set to move to the same city next summer.) A few weeks ago, we had a disagreement and he dumped me over the phone. I was so hurt, frustrated, and upset that all I wanted to do was forget about him as easily as he had forgotten about me so I slept with someone else. (Don't worry ... trust me ... I regretted it the very second I did it.) Hours later my boyfriend and I got back to together and he said he dumped me in the heat of the moment and didn't mean it. I didn't tell him what happened between me and the other person until 2 weeks later over the phone. My boyfriend was so hurt that he said it was over between us. That same day, I immediately booked a plane ticket to his city to see him in person, express my heartfelt apology face to face, etc. He did see me and hear me but still said it was over.

I know what I did was awful and very, very stupid. I don't need further beating up about it. I am genuinely sorry and have never been unfaithful to him or anyone else before. I know he is hurting right now and the last thing he wants is to be bothered. Our relationship was filled with a lot of love and trials and I just know deep in my heart that if we could work through this I would never hurt him again. I am not asking anyone to bash/analyze me for what I did. I ask:

What can I do for him to trust me again and forgive me? Should I just leave him alone right now? Should I drop hints that I still care (letters, cards)? What would a girl who has done this to you have to do for you to forgive her, trust her again, and want to work through this?


Update: Thanks guys and girls. He still says it's over. (Been 1 1//2 weeks now.) I've decided to let it go. He knows that I love him dearly and am sorry, but he can't remove the image from his head. I'm realizing I wasn't entirely listened to anyway.    A month ago

Update: The event happened on a night when he said he was going out of town at the last minute and refused to talk to me on the phone while he was in the car with his brother and friend. (He agreed to talk a bit before driving off and a bit when he got there.)    A month ago

Update: We couldn't compromise and he eventually called it quits. Though the mistake I made has potentially broken us up for good, looking back at our relationship, I think his inability to sometimes understand my side would have separated us eventually.    A month ago

3000 characters left  Anonymous Spell Check Spell Check
 Report Question Widgets Note This
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
 Share on Facebook

Answers

    From Guys  
9
From Girls  
4
 

Best Answer

Allegory
445  
Allegory      When: A month ago
Be patient, that's the key.

Honestly with relationships on both sides if people are adult and serious when trust or personal intimacy gets broken it rarely if ever gets fixed honestly.

You can't do anything other then just be patient, supportive and calmly there as a gentle reminder of what is good and really there.

I agree that you didn't cheat (moved a tad fast but didn't cheat, he needs to realize the power of his words) part of me wonders if he knew the guy since you did it in a mater of hours that makes it seem likely. If so then that's going to put the breaks on this even more so.

Honestly your 25-29 years old, if he really cares about you deeply he shouldn't care other then your his and want to be with him. The fight sounds a bit childish and I am afraid the repair will be so as well.

My advice, be a great freind and if he says it's over apologize one last time and say you understand then date someone else.

The absence will remind him what he had (it's childish I admit but honestly the fight seems to fit) and you could be very surprised that he wants you back.

My advice is find someone who doesn't breakup so dramatically and wants you no mater what. I fell for a girl hard once and can tell you I didn't care who she slept with prior as long as she was with me going forward from this point on that's all I wanted. I loved her more then anyone before and can say that is what you want to find in a guy. The rest is just more trouble down the road.

Sorry. I wish I could help more.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

What Guys Said

MadHatterni
2625  
MadHatterni      When: 6 days ago
i don't blame him, bit immature on your part...
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

pthurmond
67  
pthurmond      When: 15 days ago
Well first of all if the first thing you do when things tank with a long-time boyfriend is run out and sleep with someone else then then I don't blame him for not being able to trust you. Especially if he really had to work at it to get you to sleep with him in the first place. That is a hell of a kick in the nuts.

Now to get him to forgive you, you will have to rebuild that trust and that won't be an easy task. You can't make some grand gesture and expect him to up and trust you again. Your best bet is to keep talking with him as a friend and just be there for him. After a while he may trust you enough to give you another chance. Right now he is hurt and offended and that kind of pain doesn't go away quickly or easily.

To be honest if he is smart he isn't going to make this easy for you. Nothing against you, but cheaters tend to cheat again.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

lilcam
193  
lilcam      When: A month ago
hi. I know you have probably figured out what to do already and if you don't read this I completely understand but there is something you have to know. IF HE LOVES YOU HE WONT CARE ABOUT WHAT YOU DID AND HE WOULDN'T WANT TO HURT YOUR FEELINGS. sorry if this sounds mean and if you haven't sorted it already then I'm sorry but good luck. if you want to talk to someone I am here for you x cameron <3
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

DoggyDude
1070  
DoggyDude      When: A month ago
Its a sad situation and its good that you have learned from your mistakes.

Its a terrible pity though. It sounded like you had something together which is rare.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

stktder
261  
stktder      When: A month ago
I feel from what you are telling me, is that he is or was having a relationship behind your back. If he broke up with you before you had a relationship with another person, then it is obvious somethings wrong. Rarely does getting back together ever work out. I know that we all would love to believe that but we got to be adults about this and face facts...He broke up with you !
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

Prometheus
802  
Prometheus      When: A month ago
It's going to depend on him as a person. Personally there is nothing a girl could do for me to take her back. Once she's broken my trust that's it. However there are plenty of people who do forgive and forget and go on to be happy. All you can do is show him how much he means to you without acting like a stalker. If he does forgive you it has to be completely genuine, so many people say they do and then throw it back in the others persons face during every argument.

I think you made a silly mistake but I also think that you do genuinely love him. Maybe show him what you have put on here? That would let him know you are serious about how you feel and about being sorry.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

DrJones
1443  
DrJones      When: A month ago
OK, so it's usually not a good idea to sleep with someone that soon after a break-up... but that's for your own good, not because you owe anything to your ex-boyfriend. I don't see how you did anything wrong to him. He dumped you! That means he doesn't get to tell you what to do with your life. It's not like you cheated on him or left him for someone else.

Hell, you even had enough guts to be honest about it, even if it did take a couple of weeks. If I was in his shoes, I'd be mad at myself for breaking up with you in the first place. Of course I'd feel jealous, but I wouldn't blame you for anything. I'd try to get over my own insecurities and remind myself that you're a real catch. You told him the truth, in person, and are making a serious effort to rebuild trust and help him get over his hurt feelings. What more can you ask from a girlfriend?

I hate to say it, but I don't think this guy is boyfriend material - at least, not right now. If he thinks you should feel guilty for not being faithful *after* he dumped you, he's too self-absorbed to date anyone seriously. I'd give him a little time so you can both cool off a bit and he has a chance to get over himself since you're probably both still sort of in shock. But if he still acts like you did something bad to him, I'd start thinking about breaking up with him.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

jimmajam
1290  
jimmajam      When: A month ago
If it were me there would be nothing you could do. I would never forgive her or trust her again. Since when is sleeping with someone a good idea after a breakup? I'm sure you didn't randomly find a guy on the street and sleep with him. Which tells me and your ex that you probably had it in mind or had been flirting with the idea during your relationship. If not the fact that you get around that easily says something about you.

The only thing you can do now is give hm time. if he wants to get back with you, he'll let you know.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

Davidnorth
1148  
Davidnorth      When: A month ago
You just need to live day to day and build his trust again slowly, you can't undo a mistake like that quickly or easily. You seem to feel guilty and sorry so I would guess that in time, the two of you will get back to the point you was at and move on.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report
 

What Girls Said

Gamergirl116
91  
Gamergirl116      When: 12 days ago
Good luck honey! I hope you find someone who truly respect what you have to offer.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

blueberryhill
31  
blueberryhill      When: A month ago
hey you reacted - your human he was looking for an excuse anyway - this just set you free a little quicker without months of endless pandering to his whims - It was fine when you were apart he just couldn't face the reality of all the time - he wasn't hurt he was releived and playing hurt - think of this as a huge piece of luck - who needs a man like that !
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

smellylittlecat
935  
smellylittlecat      When: A month ago
Hey girl, you have to note this:

You guys were BROKEN up when you had sex with that other guy.
He has not right to know that you did it with him. He was no longer your boyfriend at the time.
So actually, that was nice enough for you to admit it but you guys never cheated technically. Yes you regret it because you broke up with him immediately before you had sex with this random guy. But really, it is not his concern to know that.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

 
Anonymous User
N/A  
Anonymous User      When: A month ago
I would write him emails, hand-written letters, etc. Tell him what you just wrote here. Tell him that deep in your heart and soul you know that you made a stupid mistake, and the last thing you wanted to do was hurt him. Tell him that you'll spend the rest of your life making it up to him.
But don't expect any replies. Just give him some space. He is angry right now but he will calm down. He will still be hurt but he will have some room in his mind to listen to you once he calms down. So once in a while, drop him an email or something to show that you are sorry and you care about him.
That's all you can do. That's all I can come up with. If somebody did this to me, I would want that.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report
 
Find more questions on take her back     
Home > Relationships Questions > What would she have to do for you to take her back?
 
Join GirlsAskGuys
Members earn points to get Expert Advice on Video, Amazon & iTunes Gift Cards, books and more!
Male Female
 Open Contests  
Crazy Thanksgiving Story with Family
Thanksgiving is right around the corner and just like the last year and the year before, you will most likely spend it with your family. And just like everyone else, you have a crazy uncle or an...
$20 Amazon Gift Card   $20 Amazon Gift Card
Check out the winner of the last contest!
Worst Pick Up Lines
Winner received $20 Amazon Gift Card
View All Contests >>
Questions on take her back
A Guy Asked Should I take her back?
My girl and I are broken up, but have been on and off for a little over a year. We have had such good times and she has been the best thing to ever...  
A Guy Asked Should I take her back?
My girlfriend and I have been in love for 2 years. We have had our ups and downs, but always find a way to work things out. She has recently told me...  
More Questions on
take her back
Expert Advice
More Video Answers
A Guy Asked  Question: Is cheating ever ok?

Video Answer From Tamsen Fadal
Click here to watch larger video
Relationships Xpers
  
Shlei3
14534  
Shlei3
Engaged, 26 years old
United States
6 Questions - 999 Answers
Relationships Xper: 3499
kingbrother
12252  
kingbrother
Single, 16 years old
United Kingdom
0 Questions - 1017 Answers
Relationships Xper: 3081
Hercules
14690  
Hercules
Single, 20 years old
United States
2 Questions - 734 Answers
Relationships Xper: 2619
Littletad
14615  
Littletad
Single, 26 years old
United States
5 Questions - 623 Answers
Relationships Xper: 2217

What is Xper? View Rankings
Disclaimer: GirlsAskGuys cannot guarantee the accuracy of answers, opinions and advice submitted by members. Please use common sense when following or omitting any content on GirlsAskGuys.com
Browse Categories: Flirting  |   Dating  |   Relationships  |   Sexuality  |   Break-Up  |   Behavior  |   Style  |   Other                                         Home Top
  Site Links     About GirlsAskGuys     GirlsAskGuys Widgets     Help Us Improve!   RSS Feeds
Home
Videos
Partners
Search Questions
Terms of Use, Privacy
Help, New Members
About Us
Contact Us, Send Feedback
Sitemap
Advertise With Us
Resources
Post your questions on your blog, website, or any social networking page. You can embed into MySpace, Facebook and more. Click here for more info.
Have a suggestion? See a problem on the site? Click here to give feedback and suggestions on the new GirlsAskGuys, and help us give you a better experience. Visit our blog here
 Subscribe
Add to My AOL
Add to Google Reader or Homepage
©2009 girlsaskguys.com™. All Rights Reserved.