Would a guy rather hook up with a girl with meat on them or a skinny one?

Depends on what you mean by "some meat". Girls sometimes talk down the fact that really, to be honest, they're overweight. Phrases like "curvy", "cuddly" or "something to hold on to" often mean overweight. Anyway, although I don't like super-skinny, anorexic looking girls, I prefer slim girls in general.

I'd much rather have the girl that isn't fat but has some meat on her because a girl's body looks best with shape and curves, soft and inviting. Not skin and bones.

I like girls that have a little bit more meat or curvy. When it comes to really skinny girls I am afraid of breaking them or something. Girls with curves are beautiful.

The one with no meat is out. However, I have to qualify that by saying some women in their online profiles use a very liberal interpretation to the terms "average", "a few extra pounds" or "curvy". So I go less by descriptions and more by photos or height vs weight. Call me shallow Rafael.

I could care less if a girl was really skinny, average weight, or a little overweight, as long as she has a cute face is nice and smells like a girl should, no problems. If I had to absolutely pick I too would prefer a girl with a little extra meat. A girl who is 5, 10, 15 pounds overweight is super hot in my book.

I'd rather a girl had some meat on her. When I give her a squeeze she'll be nice and soft!