Style question - all black?

That sounds incredibly appealing. However, if the girls is dressed in all black and has a gothic look with black makeup too, then it wouldn't be attractive to me.

It depends on whether or not she looks good wearing it. Just wearing a particular set of clothing isn't enough; the clothing has to accentuate her attractive features.

The little black dress is pretty much universally alluring.

Pair that with two excuses to look at a pair of shapely legs, and yeah, I would find that rather impressive, even without the long hair.

With the hair thrown in.. most guys will be trying to avoid drooling.

HELL Yeah, a brunette is all black is even better

YES!

I am no guy but I think they definitely do find it appealing! I personally think any women in black looks amazing!