Okay, so lets say the underweight girl has a bmi of 10, has her bones poking out, is so weak that she can't walk, has no boobs, and has the personality of a totally horrible mean, bitchy, and manipulative person
And then the obese girl doesn't want to stop eating, but other than that she has the most perfect personality for you.
You have to pick one or the other, and no one else. For example most of you would say you would want a healthy girl, but you can't pick that, because you have to pretend that the obese and underweight girls are your only options. Also for girls, answer which one you would rather choose, but just imagine them as guys instead.
Most Helpful Guy
I'd go single. Seriously. There's no way I'd date a person with a horrible personality, and there's no way I'd date a person that was morbidly obese. Just no chance. I wouldn't do it ever. I'd rather die alone. The horrible person I wouldn't want to be around, and the morbidly obese person is essentially committing slow suicide with the horrible level of weight. It's just as bad as chain smoking. It's disgusting and unappealing; the health consequences as time goes on- the quality of life of that person will be terrible. They can't do things I enjoy because they are too out of shape. They have no sexual appeal to me. It's just impossible to have any sort of relationship with either of them.
So I opt to be alone in that case.0