To be realistic, the first thing that'll catch my eyes, is if she's attractive and fit. But what'll make me remain interested, is if i notice she has morals, self respect, and high standards. That includes honesty, loyalty, humor, goals, and her way of thinking.
Personality. I just want to be with someone who is easy going, not overly jealous, rational and not a drama queen. It's all I want. I don't care about the size of her boobs or butt, if she is a bit overwheight or if she has stretch marks, moles, scars or if she has an outie/innie. I just want to have a good time.
Well I had a first date with a girl last weekend that went for 3 hours and she neither had big boobs or arse, yet we had an amazing connection. So definitely personality, and I would say interest in the other person. Personality leaves that lasting impression that makes you want to relive past moments.
A big horse, but honestly a personality that allows me to talk to her easily and for a long time, and for looks a cute face I like to look at and medium sized boobs, curvy but I guess although not too important