I'm not an athlete. Also the athletes get all the cute/attractive women with the nice bodies. On the contrary, I play an instrument which is the piano. Since all the cute/attractive women go for athletes and I'm no athete, I'm a musician, does this I won't get girls at all? Or am i wrong?
Nahh... Not for me. No matter what he does, the personality gets me the most. Of course it's even nicer to discover later on their talents. I'd be much more interested in hearing and seeing your piano skills then seeing a guy lifting weights. Nothing against athletes tho.
My boyfriend is a member of the choir. He also plays the piano/guitar. And we're both gamers. :D I really don't think your interest matters, unless your girl in question likes athletic types. I'm with him because he's genuinely nice and funny and a great person, not because he does sport (which he doesn't HAHA). You sound nice, stay that way and you'll be fine. Good luck in your ventures on the romance side! :)