I honestly prefer girls without makeup especially if I'm dating them or are going to be. Like I dont mind makeup on special occasions but for every day things I dont look like it. The way I see it is I'm dating YOU not Maybelline. And if I need makeup to think your attractive or if you think I do then that's a problem.
For most I'd say that can call for a minor amount of cosmetic enhancements, at least according to my preference (I've mostly lived in very urban and fashionable areas, I might have gotten used to women who dress up fancy and make themselves up).
However, there are times I see a girl without make-up. Just the other day I saw one of my female acquaintances after she got all sweaty and worked out outside with no make-up, and I was surprised how pretty she looked in spite of it with her shirt soaked in sweat and no make-up whatsoever from what I could tell. Yet she's an exceptionally attractive girl in her late 20s with or without make-up. But maybe seeing her without any (I usually see her with a bit of make-up) made me so fascinated with how pretty her face looked in spite of it.
So girls to me who look amazing without make-up are quite beautiful. There's no possible way for them to look anything but gorgeous. Yet it's only a small minority of women who have that kind of effect on me without make-up. For most, I feel like they look their best with a small amount.
Both, girls look cute when they got dark circles and acne scars, and girls also look cute when they got a black smoked out eyeshadow and heavy contouring/highlighting. I personally wear makeup a bit on the heavier/gothicish side, but I just like girls overall.