I've dated both, and hypothetically speaking, if I didn't have my son, I know I'd be better off sticking to bad boys. When a bad boy is an asshole, you're prepared for it.
Falling for a nice guy comes at the expense of your pride, your self esteem and your trust in men. The problem isn't when they're "too nice" , it's all the passive aggressive stuff that you don't see coming. But then, at the end of the day, we're partly to blame for being hurt because of our own expectations.
I would probably end up beating the nice dude up. For some odd reason if I'm with a dude who is way too nice, that tends to piss me off greatly. I don't want a dude who will take my bullshit and let me walk all over him.
I would go for the nice guy. I hate games instead of making things interested for me they do the opposite. I'm over that stage in my life so a nice living guy i know i mean the world to its just what i love and would go for