You started with looks. Anyone who places looks as a first priority when seeing a mate is superficial, and won't truly love you for who you are. Looks fade. Will she stay if you are horribly disfigured while trying to save her life?
The guy you described sounds average. I don't actually know him, so I can't actually answer your question. I judge people based on who they are and how they treat others, and I NEVER judge based on first impressions, because that's when a person is most likely putting on an act to impress you.
Those are some pretty basic attributes that don't really say much about the person at all... what are his interests? What kind of sense of humour does he have? What's his style? When you say polite, do you mean just nice or is he weirdly robotic in his interactions? Is he fun to be around or a chore to get out of his shell? Cute according to who, by the way? And frankly, even if we knew all that, without actually interacting with a guy IRL you can't tell if there's a connection or what his mannerisms are like - the little stuff that matters but can't really be put on paper.
You can't just describe a bunch of generic "positive" attributes with one minor flaw that really could mean a hundred different things and ask if the guy described is 'boyfriend material". That's not how it works.
Yes, Indeed. I would say "He" is Perfect for Someone who is More like the Rebeca of Sunny Brook Farm and Not some Hot to Trot girl who Probably would Never be Able to Appreciate a Guy like this. Good luck. xx