A girl who had a very attractive body was very anal-retentive about keeping it that way? So the first girl doesn't really care if she gains a couple pounds, but the second girl would notice and not eat junk till she loses it?
Most Helpful Guy
would really depend on how much a "couple of pounds " equates to
and if the second girl is that high strung it might carry over to the rest of her personality, which would be a turn off
but if the first girl is always eating junk food, that can be a turn off too