Scariest game you've ever play. If you can, console/ PC.
Hmm... the first two REs were pretty freaky, Dead Space was scary at first, the third one was more cool than anything. Bioshock was pretty scary. Silent Hill Downpour was scary at times, the P. T. was fucking horrifying. Nightmare Creatures could be put on here, too, I guess.
I guess it's not that scary but I love American Mgee's Alice and Alice Madness Returns. Alice was my very first video game when I was 6 I used to play it with my mom.. a bit dark for a 6 year old but I loved it!
I don't play scary video games, but I heard an urban legend about the 'red room'. It's a boy playing a video game, and a pop-up comes up that says "Do you like?". He then closes it. More pop-ups open, and these ones said 'Do you like red?'. He closes them, and even more open. These ones say 'Do you like the red room?'. There is an eerie scream, and the next day, the boy hung himself and painted his room red with his blood.