And you are?
I'm a Girl I'm a Guy Updates:
I free hand drew mine apart from the big bottom circle which I used a compass Pic 1 used a compass throughout
Pic 1 artist has been doing art classes her whole life Pic 2 artist stopped doing art classes at the age of 12 aka self taught Most Helpful Guy
Pic 1 is very technically correctly done and robot seems pristine but Pic 2 has a more earthy feel to it, robot feels more battered and shaded. I will chicken out and say both artists achieved what they wanted to do - A close tie. Both drawings are excellent.
Most Helpful Girl
The first one.
All the shading on the second one is unnecessary
What Guys Said 12
The first one is more technically accurate and the second is more aesthetically pleasing even with its asymmetry. However, the first one is in a washed out photo which makes it hard to see everything properly.
the second one. better proportions and the shading make it look better in my opinion.
the BB-8 writing sucks on both though :P
The second one is nice with the shadows but the first one has more accurate lines, much more symmtertical and proportionate. Not all the circles look as round on the second one
I'd go with the first overall but the style of the second is cool
The one that you are not.
Lol I just like to tease you Weirdo :p
pic 2 brings out the shades. Lol, of course you have shaded it. I liked it.
First one is more proportioned right.
The second one has some great detail and shading!
Pic 2 look so realistic 👌
Which one is drawn by uhh?
They're both very good...
I thought #1 was better... first thing I noticed was BB-8 didn't appear completely round in the bottom one.
Unfair, pic 2 is shaded.
Ask the artist of pic 1 to shade it.
the only difference s that one has shading and there other doesn't
They both ate good but it goes to 2
What Girls Said 14
Good job, girl. Second is better.
Definitely pic 2 😍 it looks sooo realistic 😍 great job girl!😏
Well the first one doesn't look as good and part of reason could be because it's not coloured in very good
So I choose the second one
shadows are too harsh on pic.2
I say two because head is a bit too small on the first one :p
But I prefer picture 1's style
Both are great, but I really like all that shading on the second one, it makes it look so cool😱
I like them both, but the darker tones of the second one is what got me. :)
Daamn girl, you're talented (Y)
Picture #2 looks amazing. Both pics look good, but the second is so 'wow'. I love how the artist smudged the pencil, it gave it that artsy look.
Too much shading and detail in the second one. It's too dark.
I find first one better... i donno why it has better structure...
More detail in picture 2
But both look amazing
Pic 2 , purely because of the shading...
Click "Show More" for your mentions