When I was younger and in HS, I liked the skinny/lanky and athletic type. But now I've grown to appreciate manilness in guys not only their muscle composition but also facial hair etc. Although I don't like body builders that resemble the hulk, having a muscular guy is also really sexy :) I like it when a guy towers over me, so my attraction to height has always stayed the same.
who says women like skinny weaklings? LOL. I am 21 and I am currently dating a guy with a very fit football player body. Granted I got lucky as I fell for his personality first. Did I answer your question? Personality is what it is all about. Honest, direct, respectful and determined men are the sexiest. A little goofiness doesn't hurt too. it makes them charming ;)