I am happy with little makeup but not lots of makeup. Avoid overdoing it. You are absolutely right about the rest. Keep it simple on regular days but use your creativity when it comes to special occasions.
I have no problem with make-up. Just heavy makeup. Doing yourself up for prom or the like should be taken as a compliment by your man. People are supposed to look good for the people in their life they care about when going out.
It's no such much that we don't like make up, it's when we can tell you have it and it's too much. Nothing wrong with sexy eyes and lippy, but when foundations is strong and everything else, it looks unnatural. Better to go for a natural look.
Yes. I like to know that she's naturally beautiful, and she usually keeps it that way but on special occasions it's nice to know that she can dress up too if needed.