this is too black and white you give us not middle ground to vote on it's either attractive or repulsive that's two extremes mind.ucsd.edu/.../falsedichotomy.html anyway i think they are attractive only if they are small and they go with the girls personality but once the get big they get gross
You're talking about those cigarette holder things people get in their earlobes right? I don't find any piercings attractive, but to me those are particularly repulsive. But I guess aesthetics is subjective, if you want something like that it's up to you.
Yuck. Nuff said.
No, how can a lobe that has a stretched gaping hole with a massive disk plugged in it be attractive?