C, it doesn't make her "attractive", that's not really the right word. It makes her more "naturalistic". Depending on the guy this could be a positive or negative.
Personally, I'm indifferent whether a girl wears makeup or not. I'm used to being around waitresses that will one day look like they're about to go to prom and the next like they stopped giving any f**ks after they woke up that morning. So to me, makeup is more of a "her choice" thing and it doesn't affect me too much.
If you find a girl who is attractive without make up, then yes, I like the natural girl. With make up the girl can look completely different!!! Yes, but at the end of the day if you love the person for who they are!!! Who needs the make up? Personally I love a brown eyed girl and a gorgeous smile. Top qualities I 1st look for in a woman :-)
If he is attracted to her with makeup, he is almost certainly going to be attracted to her without makeup. I know all of my eces were just as attractiv without makeup on (even though they didn't think so).
I'd say it depends. Some people are naturally attractive without make up and some are just not as attractive without some makeup :P I personally feel i look really plain unless i wear some eyeliner and even then sometimes i feel plain. But I don't really wear makeup besides eyeliner, mascara and some tinted lip products. It's a lot of effort and i'd rather not deal with the whole rub my eye, look like a raccoon ordeal.
Honestly I hate caking my face with makeup. Why would I cover up who I really am behind a mask? Yes I love dressing up and I will put more effort when it's a big event (like I'll put eyeshadow, eyeliner) but usually I'm on the go with only mascara and blush or I just wash my face and put some lotion on. If a guy or anyone for that matter does not like how I look in my natural state, with all my imperfections, I am fine with it. :)
Usually, no. Most guys say they prefer women without make up but I've noticed the same guys ignore bare faced women and chase after made up women. Fact is, guys don't typically pay attention to you if you aren't wearing make up. I've tested this out on numerous occasions.
I would say that it depends on the guy. Some guys in general don't like for women to wear make up because it hides there beauty. I look at makeup as putting a mask on your face. I personally don't bother with make up or anything like that I don't' know how to apply that stuff so I don't use it. The only thing I'll ever wear is mascara and lip stick. But I don't cake all that other stuff on my face. I honestly think women should feel confident and comfortable in there skin. They don't need make up to hide there true beauty. I've seen girls at my school cake it all on there face and I'm just like you really don't need all that make up on your face you look fine without it. Sometimes I'll just put on lip stick and mascara and be good to go. Other times every once in a while I just feel beautiful in my natural skin.