If I had to choose between the two, it would be the second option. However, I find that I am most attracted to men who do not fit either type specifically. I like a man who can get down and dirty out in nature, but when it comes time to take me out on the town cleans up well.
I voted B because I love the scruffy look, but it's really both for me. I love a guy that can switch it up. One that can look dapper and handsome in a nice suit and then come home and look just as sexy in a tshirt and jeans. Versatility is everything.