This assumes, of course, that he thinks you're good looking. What should he say? You're cute? You're hot? You're sexy? He loves your "eyes", total bs of course... or something else?
Most Helpful Girl
look for something unique you like about her, I dunno, like her smile, or dimples or something. I always get comments about my eyes so I'm just like oh thanks, but when someone comments about something not easy to notice, I take note of it. when some guy says to me "you're gorgeous" when I just meet them, my first thought is "ok, stop buttering me up because you want some tonight" so don't say "you're hot" or "you're sexy". so be truthful, don't bullsh*t1