So, I know that most of you guys say you appreciate natural beauty but, imagine this scenario:
There are two girls, one who wears makeup almost everyday, but it looks natural (eyeliner and lipstick) - nothing disturbing at all, and another who doesn't wear makeup normally (only if there's an occassion) and looks cute.
The one with the makeup looks more attractive than the one without makeup BUT they're both good-looking.
Now, if you'd see the first one without makeup, she'd look as pretty as the second one. But she never 'not' wears makeup. And let's say you'd never see her without makeup so you wouldn't realise those two girls are equally beautiful.
Which one would you prefer?
Give your honest opinions ^^
Most Helpful Guy
You said, "one who wears makeup almost everyday, but it looks natural (eyeliner and lipstick) - nothing disturbing at all." But the problem is that lipstick are the most annoying pieces of makeup a girl can wear. I don't like the sight of seeing them. Immediately from that, I would prefer the other girl who didn't wear makeup because none of the annoyances would there on a regular basis.
That being said, if the push came to shove between the two girls, I would choose either over the other on that basis because I don't think something so trivial as my annoyances for eye liner or lipstick would even factor towards choosing between the two. Looks are not enough for me consider what to be with a girl.
Ultimately, girls don't really have to look good for me to find them sexually attractive. I find other quantities in girls, that are non-physical, sexually attractive and more appealing to me. A lot things that girls do or I find annoying (such as makeup) would never be used against them or deter me for wanting to be with them. The way I see it, it's me who has the problem, not theirs and I will be not be judging them for things I don't like. It's just unfair in my opinion if I were to do such as thing.1