I'm not sure about others, but for me a girl who can wear less make-up and still look attractive is the ultimate attraction. Too much make up looks worse than too little, I see many girls who literally wear a mask and yet if they wore less they would look so much more attractive.
Basically, little to no makeup is best. Naturally, some will be all right, to accentuate some things or whatever. None at all is fine by me. A lot, to the point I actually notice it is repulsive. It gives off so many bad vibes, like insecurity and trying too hard to look good. Basic rule of thumb: less is better than more.