Depends on the girl to me, I don't think so many guys would differ. Some girls look great with no make-up or next to none, some look better with a bit, some might look best when they look almost like a different person with make-up.
Personally I prefer girls who look nice with little or no make-up, since otherwise it can be kind of a turn-off when they take off their make-up and want to have sex.
But that doesn't mean I prefer girls to wear little or no make-up, it means I prefer girls who don't need much make-up.
There's a girl at the Subway I frequent who wears a ridiculous amount of makeup, which always takes me by surprise when I go to pay. Sure, she may just like it for herself but it really puts me off slightly.
Most normal guys in the real world like some makeup when you're out to accentuate, contour, brighten your facial features. Not the no-make up butchy look, not the instagrammed-too-fake look either. It's a balance.