Guys: Does heavy eyeliner on a girl look hot, or not?

Anonymous
Hey there. (:

So, I always wear pretty heavy eyeliner. It's usually a base of black, smudged eyeliner on my lid and slightly on the bottom corners, then covered again with a dark plum to even it out. Another coat of eyeliner to shape it, and then mascara.

I've been told it looks good on me, and other times I've been told I look much prettier without it, but I'm looking for a general consensus. (I'm not emo, for the record)

Guys: Do you find heavy eyeliner attractive? Why or why not. (=
Guys: Does heavy eyeliner on a girl look hot, or not?
6 Opinion