I'm sorry but I think that love is expressed through kind words and deeds, not shiny rocks.
Most Helpful Girl
If a boy EVER bought me anything with a diamond from the morally-bankrupt De Beers cartel (= pretty much any non-manmade jewelry diamond out there)... well, then, he has neither the common-sense financial instincts nor the moral compass I need in a man.
Back to the store it goes, even if I have to create a "defect" in order to circumvent a no-returns policy. Fuck that shit.
And as for him...