Deffinitly without, I'm all for natural beauty so a girl looking her natural self is by far the hottest. I think even girls that wear make up, the less they wear the better, if anything id rather they not wear any
what I found from this website, because believe it or not this question comes up often ;) lol, is that guys say they like no makeup, but what they mean is they like the natural LOOK. I bet they like it the most when a girl looks like she's wearing no makeup, but in fact, it's just well done. Someone had once answered that a study was made on the most attractive girl... the girl with all the makeup (including foundation, bronzer... the whole works!) was the most attractive... and guys said she was probably only wearing mascara and lip-gloss... haha so they like the look... not necessarily what it entails.