Eyeliner is decent along with eye shadow. Lip gloss somewhat OK, but I see girls putting it on like a religion, in moderations are OK. Lipstick should generally be for work, going out, special occasions not everyday casual look. Foundation is OK but barely OK because a lot of it looks like clown makeup and guys don't want to touch your face and a puff of powder just explodes. If worn in moderation almost all make is alright, but find the right combination to compliment you and makeup will take you from a 8-10
Hate lipstick! It's like kissing a wax candle. Lip gloss/chapstick isn't so bad, but that colored crap tastes terrible, feels terrible, and makes you look terrible. My wife didn't even get married in lipstick because I hate it so much. She's a gloss girl.
Makeup is not going to make or break the way I feel about a girl, if I really love someone I won't care what they wear on their face. Personally, if wearing makeup makes her feel better about herself, then I don't mind. However, I find that most girls I know/am friends with who frequently wear makeup often look just as good, if not better, without it.