A little eye liner and mascara is always nice. And if a girl goes the extra mile with a little cover up, I always appreciate the extra effort. If I see a girl and her face is orange or her freckles have disappeared, then there is an issue.
its not about what makeup items you apply but the end result is what matters. no offense but this is one of the most asked questions on this site. look at the girls that guys think are most attractive -- how much makeup are they wearing? honestly it really just depends on what you like. there are some girls that don't like wearing makeup and some that love it. as long as you look good who cares