lol I think I would perfectly go in with girl number 2 (but I'm a guy!):P but with out the chubby part lol :D
most people say personality is most important but its not true its always about da looks if you look good then you gonna get a sexy girl or guy but if you ain't lookin good then you ain't gonna get da sexy 1s
girl 1 is clearly trying to present herself well and, frankly, people who are exclusionary to just their circle of friends can still have fantastic personalities. Frankly, girl 1 sounds like an amazing girl. The rest seem to have problems with personality (3) or effort to present herself well (2).
its all important, but girl 1 hasn't don't anything wrong, and the rest of the stuff she is doing right.
would you want an attractive popular guy, who wears all the clothes you love the most, is in good shape, and whose friends consists mostly of the 30 guys he plays with the football team after school every day and seemed to be well liked by those he hung out with. His personality is not specifically discussed.
a guy with an really great personality but is out of shape a bit, don't really do anything with his hair or shave properly and wears that one Pittsburgh Steelers superbowl t-shirt a few too many times a month for it to possibly always be fresh. but everyone knows him and thinks he's pretty cool!
A guy who frankly is nerdy looking and has lots of zits. He seems extremely quiet and doesn't say all that much. He's pretty boring to talk to. But lord does he know how to party.
thats what you just presented to us. The choice is OBVIOUS.