I'm terribly shallow when it comes to this, but the guy has to be at least mildly pleasant looking for me to give him the green light. It's rather bad of me, I know, but it's just kind of a natural thing for me: You could be the sweetest guy in the world, but if you aren't mildly attractive I just couldn't. I just wanted to know how many people are like this?
They are the starting point of attraction for me, not gonna lie about that. But personality is the biggest deciding factor for me. I'm fine with a girl who is pretty and getting to know, but if she has a poor personality, I wouldn't bother.
It's not bad for you to feel that way at all! I feel the same way about girls, as long as they aren't super ugly or fat, I'm willing to give them a chance. Looks do matter, to everyone. Otherwise someone's age wouldn't matter at all! Love is never blind.