Hmm.I'd say average, though I don't mind guys being *somewhat* athletic, as in, muscular, but NOT veins-bulging, neck-that's-bigger-than-my-body, ugly muscles like some body-builders go for.
But like I said, I fall for average guys in general. In my experience, other body types usually have undesirable personalities that go with them: cocky, whiny, b****y, etc. Notice I said USUALLY. I realize there are great guys in all body types. Just gotta get past the jerks to find them.
I voted average because there's not a category for my type of a guy.
He should be kinda on a skinny side, but still more average than skinny. A strong body, endurable. xD Broad shoulders, narrow hips, firm arms, but not body-builder kind, just strong, but not too big (that's such a turn off). Abs are completely not important in this story.