generally it is the natural beauty that atracts man to woman. I think make up is usually on the face and I it is safe to say men are attracted to so much more of a woman than a pretty face. I prefer a girl who does not wear make up because make up is used to embelish natural features but if her eyes are beautiful you don't need to highlight them with liner, mascara, or eye shadow.
I generally don't because I generally prefer heavy eye make up and drawn on eye brows but generally guys in the us do like like a make up as long as its you don't look like a clown (even though it tends to be the opposite on gag)
The majority of guys like girls who wear make-ups because they want girls to look good and girls do look good with make-up but not those with TONSof make-up on their face, ugh. I respect the guys who don`t make a bug deal out of girls wearing make-up. I personally hardly wear any bar eye-liner and mascara (rarely, my eye lashes are already pretty long) and clear lip gloss if my lips go chapped.
They prefer girls do what looks best. Most girls need some amount of makeup to look decent, but there are some, SOME, who are basically naturally flawless and gorgeous. They can say they'd prefer but at the end of the day most girls don't look too good being all natural.