I have a dry sense of humor and a sort of deadpan delivery. It's similar to Jon Stewart's humor, but in my own sort of way. I find it goes over a lot of people's head, and they just give me a weird look.
I really think it depends on the girl & her personality- as it is with anything else. I, normally don't, except for I met this guy and he had a dry sense of humor, as well; but it was super funny. At first I was like 'is he joking, or is he serious?' The more I got to know him, the funnier I thought he was. It was something different, compared to the playful humor most guys have, and he sure made me laugh. (:
I love it, but I'm the same way. And yes, it goes over a lot of people's heads. Sometimes people that don't know me very well will make a joke, and I'll make one back, completely straight-faced, and they apologize and explain to me that they were just joking because they think I didn't get the joke, when really, I got the joke---they didn't get that I was joking back. ;/
I prefer witty and dry to anything else, because that's the same sense of humor I have. I, in fact, think its even more funny if some one cracks a joke and it goes over everyone's head. The weird looks are worth it when you find someone with a similar sense of humor.
People like simple humor. Mainly because we are simply feeble minded people. Most of the time people only get dry humor when they are intelligent. Think of it this way what gets higher ratings on TV, Family Guy or King of the Hill? Family Guy right? That's because its simple and stupid and that's what's entertaining. So you figure it out.