I agree with the comment suggesting that men prefer just enough makeup to enhance natural beauty. More specifically, do things like cover up blemishes with a base that matches your skin tone, and wear lipstick that suits your style. Tons of eye shadow or blush is excessive. Focus on emphasizing those traits that make you desirable.
too much makeup ends up ruining your natural face.
and it looks pretty try-hard...
guys like you to wear just enough make up to enhance your natural prettiness without looking over done like a clown. They like it to LOOK natural even if it's not how you look naturally without make up.