They would definitely like the eyes, the don't generally love the look of bright lipstick. But don't go too bold on the eyes either just make those the main focus of your makeup.
Lining in between your top lashes, a line above your top lashes, and then a line in between your bottom lashes and then adding mascara to all your lashes makes your eyes pop without looking too over the top. Use a natural shade ranging from brown or brownish black or black depending on how light your skin eyes and hair are.
Definitely EYES! I love making eyes stand out with nothing on lips. Plain eyes and bright lips seem unbalanced to me. But I know a lot of people who prefer that type of make-up style. I just love bold, smokey, captivating eyes... but everything else has to be subtle - lips, blush etc