I think I would go for Cute but that because I assign meanings to words that are not necessarily there definition and to me Pretty is the word I use when I think a girl is good look and attractive, but for a reason beyond explanation I have no feeling of attraction for them. It's like saying "you are very good looking, just not my type." in truth I feel guilty for not have any attraction because then I go through a thing of "they are fine, why don't I feel any attraction? What is wrong with me".
to me Cute is good looking and I do have an attraction, but they are not full on hot. Cute last longer wile hot tends to taper out around 30.
I can go either way, I'm attracted to beauty but at the same time anyone can be truly beautiful as well. It just depends on the persons opinion. It doesn't take that much to get me interested in a woman, nice beautiful eyes, gorgeous smile, and nice medium to long hair. That can be anyone, just depends.