it looks like you are wearing eyeliner! what makeup are you wearing?
ha ha I actually just went through something similar today. eyeliner is part of my daily routine...eyeliner on top, slight touch on the bottom, and mascara. but lately I have been noticing women wearing just mascara and eyeshadow and it looks very soft and pretty plus my eyes have a natural definition (I have dark eyelids and deep set eyes, like a natural shadow as long as I wear concealer on the bottom). so today I put on just mascara and concealer, no liner. it made me feel kind of naked but no one even seemed to notice the difference!
Well, I checked out your other pictures and you look pretty much the same, to me... When it comes to other make-up you could use, I have no idea, I'm sure some female could answer that... But as a guy, I'm saying you look good with and without the eyeliner :)
Honestly, I think you look better without all of the eye liner on. It's a more "natural beauty" look. If you want to tone it up, use a little more mascara and make your eyelashes "flair out" per say. You could also try to line your eyes with a dark eye shadow. I am quite amazed that you can't wear eye liner though.
You're pretty. I think it looks pretty good. I never liked eyeliner, always wore mascara and a little bit of liquid eyeliner on my top lid but that was about it. As for pencil eyeliner I never liked it. But anyway I think you look good, and you kind of look like my sister.