Liquid or pencil eyeliner?
girls, which one do you like better? why? have you tried them both?
Updates: Most Helpful Girl
They all suck..if you buy sh*tty quality.
Liquid can get crusty and cruchy and crinkle crumbs on your eye. Or when it isn't pigmented...leave a transperant line on your eye. Pencil can suck becaue it smears too much..every pencil I tried has always smeared. As for gel liners...I find them a tad better that liquid atm...I have the loreal one and I like it...it can get a little dry though. #TeamGelLiner
What Guys Said 2
Disclaimer : CoffeeCoffeeCoffee is not gay in any kind of way, he is a product of his upbringing lol
Not sure if this is common sense but with the pencils, if you use a lighter to heat up the 'lead' for 2 seconds and then apply, it tends to go on darker and more consistantly then normal. So you'll have the neatness of the pencil with the consistancy of a liquid :P
What Girls Said 14
Both for different things. I use pencil when I'm doing the whole smokey eye thing, or wearing it with any shadow really. It blends better. I use liquid (well I use a pen, but it's liquid - just easier to use) when I'm just wearing eyeliner on its own.
Liquid. It stays on and looks cleaner.
it depends on the look I'm going for.If I want something bold then I use liquid.if I want a softer look then I use a pencil.
pencil from sallys because one little error on the liquid and its burning the shattongagas out of you're eye but both are easy to put on and look good
Liquid for top, pencil for waterline. I like liquid more -only- because I'm still searching for a pencil that is long lasting.
You can do so much more with a pencil liner, to me liquid looks to sharp and fake.
I have them both, but use the pencil more frequently.
Pencil for me. I've used both and although the line is crisper and more dramatic with liquid, I'm pretty lazy and like how I don't have to be too precise or focused when I'm using pencil.
I've only tried the pencil but my friends say liquid is better; guess I gotta go out and get one
I have tried both and I don't use either of them regularly.
i wear liquid on top. gives you a smooth line. and I like wearing pencil on the bottom. for smokey eyes, pencil on top.
Pencil because liquid is too messy and hard to use, also harsh
Although, the liquid is clearer and good in drawing the lines.. but it makes my eyes look abnormally big and it bothers me... and when I happen to wash my face the black color will be all over my face and I will look like a panda! lol But the pencil is neater and shows the shape of the eye in a clean way! In general, I don't like putting make-up! I use it only when I have a party, because it bothers me! -_-"
I tired them both, I like liquid it looks slighty better.
Click "Show More" for your mentions
Select as Most Helpful Opinion?
You cannot undo this action. The opinion owner is going to be notified and earn 7 XPER points.