I know guys generally don't prefer girls with makeup but I think what they mean is they don't like girls wearing too much make up, so how much is too much, and what kind of makeup you guys like,
Most Helpful Guy
For daily wear, eyeliner and lip gloss should be plenty. Obviously there are times when dressing up is appropriate, so I don't have a problem with more on those occasions, but for all of the women who need 30+ minutes to do makeup before leaving the house to go to the grocery store or the gym, you're doing WAY too much.
I hate that women feel like they HAVE to do all of this crap in order for guys to find them attractive, because that is SO not the case. The truth is that women do this because they feel they are competing with other women, and because those other women pressure them to do so. It isn't the guys, it's the girls, who push for more makeup and more products all the time.16