Without, definitely. Nail polish always damages the picture of natural beauty. The exception is a transparent nail polish the application of which is almost invisible (some girls say they need it because of nail fragility, low quality nails etc. - isn't transparent nail polish a logical way out!)
The one and only colored nail polish which looks cool to me is dark-blue one when used by fair-haired women. Painters know something called complementary contrast - dark blue nail polish on blondies only validates it.
Guys rarely even notice nail polish :\ lol I put it on whenever I'm out with a guy and even if they do they just like it and especially if you bite your nails a lot like me painting them makes them look so much better.
I honestly don't think it matters much.Its like saying,"Do you think girls look better with a bracelet on,or no bracelet?" Its pretty irrelevant because "nail polish" is usually not the first thing you notice on a girl.There are plenty of others things that will catch your eye. :)
I'm a nail polish junkie, so my answer is a little biased...lol I believe that your nails are accessories. You can put any color, design, etc. on them and really put together your entire outfit. So yes, I do think girls look better with polish.
Without. But I'm in the group of as little makeup as possible on the daily. IF there is a special occasion, yeah get all dolled up. BUT if its a normal day like 355 days out of the year, little to no makeup + nail polish etc
I'm pretty detailed-oriented so I love girls who have creative nail designs or bright nail colors. It shows creativity and you're not afraid to stand out. I definitely notice! Put my fav sports team colors and I love you forever :P Besides...it gives me an excuse to touch their hands XD
I don't pay any attention to nails or polish and am neutral. I have a friend that says he thinks painted nails make "women look like whores"...never quite understood that...seems a little like a waste of time to me...but if that is what she wants it's OK by me...(:(:(: