When I examine my past, most guys I liked, was involved with, was attracted to, etc...are actually somewhere between 5"7 and 5"9!
I think a really tall guy is attractive in theory, but based on my "history" I find myself attracted to the shorter ones. Not really short, if he's under 5"7 he is usually too small for me, but I find 5"8-5"9 my perfect height ,and what I usually go for.
Then again, I'm 5"1. So I'm not in that 90 percent of women, probably, because I'm in the shortest 10% of the female adult population.
A lot of times, I will estimate that guy is on the taller side, like most of these guys who were 5"8 or 5"9 appeared tall to me, I would have guessed they were an inch or two taller, but they tell me they are a bit short. I guess to a small girl that height is fairly tall though, even if it is slightly below average or just average at best.