What about a girl wearing sneakers, t-shirts and jeans with her hair up and no makeup VS a girl that's more put together and girlie looking? I wear lace lingerie but I very rarely wear feminine clothes and accessories.
Just be real, if your comfortable with no makeup and your hair up in jeans and sneakers, the guy your with will probably not be able to keep his hands off you when you do dress up for a formal event. I personally love that style of living keep it simple stupid
If we are just talking clothing I prefer a girlie girl, but there is the person in the clothing. I have been attracted to girlie girls, sporty girls and everything in between. As long as the girl is attractive to me.