Many guys judge on outward beauty alone but you should go for the ones that care about how beautifully you or they are inside because it matters most. don't worry about make up if you don't want it, you'll get guys with better personalities without it.
Less is better. That or the barest minimum needed. I don't like warpaint on a woman's face unless she is out hunting, at the football game or conducting and ancient cultural ritual. Leave the artwork on canvas, not on skin.
Guys like girls that look good enough to not have to wear much make up. =P Having a cute face naturally is obviously attractive. Having so much make up on that when you take it off it's hard to recognize you as the same person is obviously disappointing, and a bit disgusting due to her being so fake (one big lie). Many guys find a girl's face to be the most attractive part of her. It's what you remember in your mind and what you wake up next to in the morning. So, yes if you look good enough without make up to attract your man whoever he may be and whatever his preferences in women are then he will like it.
From my experience guys don't like make up for the sake of make up. They like the effects of makeup. The dramatic eyes, sexy lips etc. The same guy who enjoys makeup on a girl, would not like to drink from her straw if it has lipstick on it.
I wouldn't worry about it. most guys are fine either way. Girls fret about appearance way more than guys notice.
If you haven't noticed already, guys tend to really go for the girls who make an effort to look pretty. i.e. nails, hair and makeup done + cute outfit. Don't put on gobs of makeup but but on a little bit so it will accentuate your features.