So I made a before and after picture, using myself as a model. I do think some girls look really good without make-up, but I don't think I'm one of them. I don't think I'm ugly without it, I just look better with it.
So, which do you prefer?
Sorry for the overdone question, but hey! I included a picture! :D
You look good in both. Even with your make-up on you still manage to look like yourself and not completely different. It's really difficult to choose one just because you still look like "you" in the other one. You're blessed with lovely skin and therefor you should count yourself as lucky. Many girls who wear make-up have skin problems and want to hide blemishes while you already have good skin.
It's like taking a picture with your iPhone and then comparing the picture before and after clicking "enhance". The difference is so subtle that unless you're going somewhere special I would prefer no make up.
You look pretty either way. I"d go with just eye liner and mascara, for the lips an invisible gloss or no gloss at all and you're good to go. I"m very good with make up do all sorts of stuff with eye shadow liners and different lip sticks and glosses :d but on an everyday basis I usually just put some mascara on and just a little bit of gloss. :)
I feel like I cant' go without makeup because I don't have clear skin. I hate it
You look nicer with eyeliner when comparing both those pictures but it may just be because the first pic has darker lighting around the eyes and the second pic is brighter around your eyes while the eyeliner draws attention to your eyes.
You can definitely go without gloss, or a shade that's much nuder.
You look good without make up too but I think the eyeliner does bring a nice definition.