I look at how he responds to me. If He doesn't care about my feelings, then I don't care. I like a guy to be funny. I also look at his personality. Physical looks don't matter to me. Yeah it helps, but your an honest, sweet, funny, caring guy then your food in my book :)
I look for looks first because I have to be attracted to him then personality. I love a guy who can make me smile :) and laugh I love a guy who has a great sense of humor,and who isn't afraid to be himself around me or my friends and I love a guy who doesn't try to impress me.
don't get me wrong, all 4 are important to me, and I wouldn't go for anyone who didn't have all four, but it's just the order girls notice first
When I first meet a guy I look at whether he can hold a charming conversation. Physically I look of course like every girl whether he has a cute/handsome face. Secondly would be his arms and hands - whether they are tan and strong or not:)