I've never really minded when people where taller then me. I'm very content being 6'3". I'm in the 97 percentile for height, so your notion of "I know most guys just want a girl that's not taller than him" doesn't really apply. It's not a I would feel inferior sort of situation, there's none of that going on. I just don't find tall women all that attractive. As I've said before on here, tall women generally come in one of two packages. Either 1) They are tall and slim ectomorphs that are really bony with no butt, and many times small boobs or, 2) they have are muscular mesomorphs that look like amazonian women. 1) seems too scrawny with no curves, many times looking anorexic which I don't like, 2) seems kind of masculine which obviously is a turn off. To generalize I'd say girls between 5' and 5'6" are generally more famine in my eyes.
I guess I'd consider a girl who is 5'8" to be fairly tall. Too tall (for me) would be taller than me - I'm 5'11". Tall girls 5'9"-6'ft can look very beautiful, but then I think about sleeping with them and it just seems kind of weird to me. Can't explain why.
In my country average male height is 5'11 so girls your height are shorter than most guys and not considered tall by any means. I generally prefer girls on the tall side of averege (which is what your height is to me). My girlfriend is 5'8 1/2 and she is hot!
I consider that a little taller than average maybe by an inch but its a good height.
I'm 6'5 and I probably wouldn't date a girl smaller than 5'5. All guys are bothered about really is that the girl isn't taller than him. The same applies for girls, not many girls would date a guy shorter than her !
I'm like 5'7 and a quarter haha. I don't feel too tall, but I'd rather date a guy that's 5'11 at least. Only because 5'9 is average and also not much taller than me at all. I feel too tall when I wear heels. I know I wouldn't want to be shorter than 5'5 though. And guys don't get mad if you're not 5'11+ because my height or taller isn't average for girls.
I think you have the perfect height, not short and not really tall. I actually envy grls your height because I'm really short and at 21 they still look at me as a kid or like a kid because they think I'm younger than my real age because I'm small. Lol