I would go for the second girl, simply for the facts she has pretty face, with light make-up, she dresses conservative (perhaps a little too conservative) but all the same, she appears to be the better choice for me. In regard to her shyness, I am hopeful and pretty sure that as we spend time together she will break out of her shyness toward me even if she remains shy in public.
Girl number one seems to be a bit too out there for me and I really find excessive make-up too much of a turn off to even give consideration.
of corse there going to choose pretty face + great body. the rest is irrelevant. a shy person can become forward. a not attractive person, well harder to change. but anyways you can't really say someone is not pretty. because everyone has different taste. post pics.