Well, of all possible makeup variations and styles I prefer smoky eye makeup. So yes, I like it in almost all cases, however choose proper colour and shape according to your face features for best effect. And I don't agree that most guys like girls without makeup, because many of them are not aware you are wearing it and think it's your natural look.
I like it on girls with black hair, an unatural hair color(pink, blue, purple), and some blondes. If it's done right it's very attractive, if it's done wrong she looks like she's tired, or just crazy. It can look good, but you have to be pretty, have one of the hair colors listed above, and do it like the third or first link. The second girl did not look attractive with the smokey eye.
It can look incredibly sexy if done correctly. Try not to overdo it.
My fiance always says he likes my eyes without all the makeup. When I ask him about makeup related things he doesn't ever really have an answer partially because he doesn't care, and partially because he honestly doesn't know anything about it. From what I've heard/read many men like a more natural look in general, but again most don't really know what that is. Generally speaking of course, I couldn't assume this is true for all men.