I'm going to respectfully disagree with some of the replies on this one. He has no interest in your changing. He is stringing you along on the off-chance that he doesn't find someone else to replace you. NEVER believe it when guys moan about how they don't want to flirt with anyone else. Either he is your boyfriend or not and this guy totally sounds like he wants to keep you on the hook but not have to deal with the responsibility (and probably monogamy) of the relationship.
I know it sucks to read that but it sounds as if this guy is completely shallow and has no consideration for your feelings. Men and women both do this. Control is much more important then his desire to shape you into something. He is playing a control game with you. I can appreciate your being confused by all of this but what you should do is step back and analyze the situation from your point-of-view and not his. You are the one who he told didn't meet up to his standards. You should not have to put up with that nonsense from anyone.
If I am wrong and he has legitimately addressed issues with you that you have no desire to change then you need to look at yourself. But, taking what you wrote at face value, he has no interest in a serious relationship with you and is stringing you along just in case he doesn't find someone else.
Most Helpful Opinions
It sounds like he really doesn't want to break up with you, but he is trying to shock you into making some change to yourself or your life. The most interesting thing in your question is the quote from him that you were not improving yourself enough to make you both happy.
You need to get to the bottom of this. What is it about you that he expects you to improve? Once you have figured that out you can make a decision whether this guy has an unreasonable expectation of you or not. He obviously has strong feelings for you yet he clearly feels embarrassed about dealing with the issue (whatever it is) direct.
If you think he's being unreasonable about what he wants you to change then you need to let him know that he needs to take you as you are, or break ties. If you think you can make the changes that he wants, and you think that he's justified in asking for those changes, AND you think he's worth it, then you have the right to be able to demand some changes/compromise yourself. However, be aware that it's very difficult for people to change and a relationship should not really be built on the understanding that one partner is going to change in the future.
How old is he. I would say just be friends, but start seeing other guys. He may just be a big turkey and need to see you with some other people before he realizes how much he cares for you.
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
2Opinion
Wow!
What a story, obviously he wants you so much. It seems that he's doing this so you know that you can be his girlfriend again, ONLY if you change - that's likely what he's thinking.
Cheers :)He's obviously a bit of a player, I think you're better off without, leave him to flirt with other ladies.
Learn more
Most Helpful Opinions