The people who have high potential must receive the most criticism so they can take advantage of their potential, but for the people with no potential the attitude is to not kick a dog while it's down.
I agree to a certain extent. I think it's down to how the girl comes across in her post.
If she's like "Hey guys, I'm fucking hawt aren't I?" she'll probably get a more negative response from guys and girls alike, because not many people like arrogance like that.
If she's sweet though, I think most guys give an honest answer. It might seem overly critical sometimes, but that's just peoples taste and most girls want honest opinions anyway or there's no point in asking.
I haven't noticed.. that does happen but not a lot. I can b bitchy to the attention whores (male ones too) cuz they annoy me.. other than those.. pretty ones are pretty.. average are average.. fats are fat.. I am truthful about all that
Gag guys are nice to the less supposedly unattractive ones? I've never seen that! From what I see some of the guys are rude to aalllll, like they have to bring up some tiny flaw and be unnecessarily critical to the attractive ones and claim they are being helpful to the supposedly unattractive ones by giving harsh criticism.